Multi-boutique model shows signs of stress

Learn and remember For individual boutiques and prospective boutiques there are some simple lessons. The first is to do your research and seek quality advice before making a decision on whom to partner with. It is surprising how few investment managers, who pride themselves on the quality of their market and security research, fail to do adequate research prior to committing to a business partner.

By definition, the multi-boutique providers have done many boutique deals whereas an investment professional will rarely do more than one. The odds are therefore stacked in favour of the multi-boutique provider when they sit down to agree terms with a new boutique.

There are multiple variations to the boutique model from the QIC-style single brand, 100-per- cent institutionally owned to the Challenger multi-brand majority investment professional-owned. Different multi-boutique providers offer different services of varying quality and at very different prices.

Shareholder and distribution agreements between the investment professionals and the institutional backer also show large variation from one provider to the next. The number and range of boutiques already in the multi-boutique provider’s stable should also be a key consideration.

Finally, and possibly most importantly, is the culture of the business you are partnering with. Building a successful fund- management business regardless of the model requires patience, commitment and a shared business philosophy from all stakeholders. Success will only be achieved if the underlying boutique and the institutional partner have a true partnership approach and similar time horizons.

For the multi-boutique providers there are clear lessons, too. It is essential to invest in developing the optimum operating model in terms of which, how and at what cost the various services will be provided to the underlying boutiques. Researching potential managers thoroughly before committing to a new partnership is also vital. Regardless of the model, the services offered and the dollars spent, unless the manager is high quality and the investment proposition credible and differentiated, the partnership will definitely not succeed.

Avoid over-promising to prospective new boutiques, as it will only lead to disappointment and tension in the future. Be wary when acquiring equity positions in established boutiques: investment professionals are paid to buy low and sell high. A boutique willing to sell part of their business is unlikely to do so unless the prospective bidder can add significant value to its business or the business has limited potential for growth.

Looking forward, the good news for boutiques and multi-boutique providers is that investors – in particular institutional investors – and their advisers continue to support businesses that display a clear alignment between portfolio managers and their clients.

, , , , , , , , , , , ,

Leave a Comment

‘Bang, fizzle, pop’: AustralianSuper CIO laments late tilt to AI

The outgoing chief investment officer of AustralianSuper Mark Delaney said one of the biggest regrets he will have as he leaves the $410 billion fund is not going overweight on the AI and digital thematic in public markets sooner, as the nation’s most powerful allocator reflects on the investment case of the technology sector in the superannuation summit in New York last week.

Sort content by